These pins were a first run of the design before being remade. The rose gold has a yellowish tint which is uneven throughout. They are pretty scratchy as well but you don't notice it much in normal light.
I didn't grade any of them so you may receive an A grade afterall but most likely they will be seconds. Honestly it was just too much of a hassle to sort them all when I was having them remade >3< Please adopt these babies.